• LOGIN
  • Make a premium of Australian life
유투브주소 : Chisholm elects first female Chinese-Australian MP but historic win leaves a community dividedChisholm elects first female Chinese-Australian MP but historic win leaves a community divided 

Chisholm elects first female Chinese-Australian MP but historic win leaves a community divided

 

 

A man applauds a man who is waving.PHOTO: Gladys Liu will head to Canberra with the mantle of history on her shoulders. (ABC News: Marco Catalano)

 

After a frenetic campaign and a long count, Chisholm has finally made history.

 

Liberal Gladys Liu will become the first Chinese-Australian woman to sit in Federal Parliament'sLower House after notching a surprise victory in the suburban Melbourne seat, securing Scott Morrison a majority Government.

It wasn't meant to be this way. A few months ago Coalition strategists had almost written off Ms Liu's chances.

 

The sitting MP Julia Banks had already damaged the Liberals and infuriated branch members when she spectacularly quit the party for the crossbench.

The ALP candidate, Taiwan-born Jennifer Yang, was a seasoned political campaigner.

And Labor's confidence quickly grew as Ms Liu's campaign was battered by seemingly endless controversies.

First the Prime Minister had to defend his candidate after Ms Liu found herself in hot water over comments she made about same sex marriage in 2016.

Then she became enmeshed in a series of bewildering minor scandals, including an abusive online post about Jennifer Yang written by Ms Liu's sister, and confusion over whether Ms Liu was still a multicultural ambassador for the AFL.

The constant barrage of headlines clearly frustrated Ms Liu, who suspected her political enemies were trying to sabotage her campaign.

"The negative news always came out of thin air," she told the ABC on election day.

"It must have been started by someone and incited by someone.

"No matter who it is or what the motive is, it is aimed at distracting me from my campaign."

All the noise might have taken some paint off the Liberals, with voters delivering a swing of around 2.2 per cent to Labor.

But that wasn't enough for Ms Yang, who is now trailing by more than 1,200 votes with more than 80 per cent of the vote counted. 

That means Ms Liu looks set to hand the Coalition its crucial 76th seat in the Lower House.

Campaign to rally Chinese-Australian community support

 

Chisholm wasn't only the tightest lower house contest in Victoria; it was also a fascinating test of which major party is winning the battle for hearts and minds in a nation transformed by immigration.

 

Both Labor and the Coalition mounted an intense campaign for votes inside the seat's large Chinese-Australian community.

Analysts mused about how the foreign interference debate or the Coalition's hawkish stance towards Beijing might sway the outcome, but those who knocked on doors in Chisholm say most Chinese-Australians were firmly focussed on issues closer to home.

In the end, hostility to Labor's flagship economic promises — particularly its plans to curb negative gearing and overhaul franking credits — poisoned Ms Yang's chances.

Like many other voters in Chisholm, large numbers of Chinese-Australians worried that Labor's policies would unfairly punish pensioners or drive down house prices that have already tumbled in the past year.

ALP campaigners accuse the Coalition of running a scare campaign on both fronts.

Ms Yang said on election day that plenty of locals had concerns about Labor's agenda, but "unfortunately, we are unable to reach all the voters who have perhaps believed the wrong information."

There's also raw frustration in Labor about the way campaign headquarters handled the hostility.

"The franking credits [policy] ruined us in Chisholm, negative gearing [policy] ruined us," said one Labor party official.

"We wanted to run lines against the Liberals, but we were just told — 'don't respond, pivot to something else.' It didn't work."

Politicians used Chinese social media app to sway voters

 

Both Labor and the Coalition also took to Chinese social media sites like WeChat to woo voters, with heavyweights from both major parties spruiking their agenda.

But WeChat was also a petri dish for fake news and misinformation.

Some users accused Labor of planning to introduce a massive inheritance tax, while another circulated doctored tweets from "Bill Shorten" declaring that Labor would boost migration from the Middle East.

Others claimed falsely that the ALP would bring in more than one million refugees over a decade if it won power.

Labor accused the Coalition of orchestrating a "desperate scare campaign" and wrote to WeChat's parent company two weeks before election day to complain. But in private they admitted there was little they could do.

Pinning down who was behind the posts was difficult. Last week the ABC revealed that some of the WeChat users spreading fake news had travelled to Parliament House with Ms Liu to meet Liberal politicians.

But Ms Liu insisted the WeChat groups they set up were not part of her campaign for Chisholm, and she could not control what her backers said on social media.

"I do have many supporters in the Chinese and the broader community, as do my opponents, and I don't think it's either fair or reasonable to expect me or anybody else to monitor or sanction the activities on social media," she said.

 

Unsurprisingly, the campaign ended in a final spasm of controversy after the Coalition printed Chinese language posters in the distinctive purple tones of the Australian Electoral Commission instructing locals how to vote Liberal.

Ms Yang accused the Coalition of trying to mislead new arrivals by implying the Liberal Party enjoyed formal backing from the federal bureaucracy.

"The poster was trying to pretend it was coming from the authorities, which in some way does have a huge influence on ethnic communities, especially for first migrants' communities," she said.

But the Australian Electoral Commission said the posters didn't break any laws, and refused to investigate.

'The problem is deeper than just this campaign'

 

Unsurprisingly, both major parties draw different lessons from the battle for Chisholm.

The Coalition is buoyed by its victory and believes it is a harbinger of good things to come.

One Liberal Party source argues Labor's traditional hold on many migrant communities is loosening. He says the Chisholm result shows how many Chinese-Australian community are drawn to the Coalition's promise of reward for aspiration.

"The lesson here is that our core message resonates in this community," the source said.

"It's not monolithic, that's what Labor assumed for years. But if you have a sophisticated campaign that uses the right channels to get our key messages across, people respond to that."

Labor is still incensed about the result. Strategists say that Ms Liu stayed competitive by running scare campaigns and only managed to eke out a victory because of the persistent and deliberate misinformation circling on WeChat and other platforms.

"Of course it was deliberate. At the very least the Liberals turned a blind eye," said one ALP source.

"It wasn't the crucial factor but it cost us, and look at the [small] margin — it was decisive."

"The problem is deeper than just this campaign, and it's not limited to WeChat. Fake news thrives on social media, and we have to work out how we counter that next time."

But that's next time.

Right now, Gladys Liu is coming to Canberra.

 

List of Articles
No. Subject Date

'Slaughter' house: The scandal insid...

  • Registered Date: May 24, 2019

'Slaughter' house: The scandal inside ANZ It was a little past midnight and a silver Porsche Cayenne was doing doughnuts across the lush fairways of the five-star golf resor...

'Swastika cupcakes': private chats o...

  • Registered Date: May 23, 2019

'Swastika cupcakes': private chats of neo-Nazis who stacked Young Nats Secret conversations between neo-Nazis who tried to take over the NSW Young Nationals have been uncove...

Chisholm elects first female Chinese...

  • Registered Date: May 22, 2019

Chisholm elects first female Chinese-Australian MP but historic win leaves a community divided PHOTO: Gladys Liu will head to Canberra with the mantle of history on her shoulders. (...

Jim Chalmers willing to battle Antho...

  • Registered Date: May 21, 2019

Jim Chalmers willing to battle Anthony Albanese for Labor leadership in federal election 2019 aftermath By political reporter Henry Belot PHOTO: Jim Chalmers has served as Shadow Fi...

Election 2019: How the polls got it ...

  • Registered Date: May 20, 2019

Election 2019: How the polls got it so wrong in predicting a Labor victory By Paige Cockburn and Bellinda Kontominas PHOTO: Even the NT News' psychic croc, Burt, made a bad call...

Bob Hawke, Australia's 23rd prime mi...

  • Registered Date: May 17, 2019

Bob Hawke, Australia's 23rd prime minister, dies aged 89 Bob Hawke, Australia's 23rd prime minister and Labor Party legend, has died at the age of 89 Mr Hawke led the countr...

Record early voting might delay elec...

  • Registered Date: May 16, 2019

Record early voting might delay election result Millions of Australians seem to want this election over already, with a record number casting pre-poll votes this year. Yet in a crue...

Australian feared dead after fatal m...

  • Registered Date: May 15, 2019

Australian feared dead after fatal mid-air seaplane collision in Alaska Photo: Four people have been confirmed dead after two seaplanes collided mid-air. (Supplied: Ryan Sinkey) An ...

Bitter Q&A spat over Newstart pa...

  • Registered Date: May 14, 2019

Bitter Q&A spat over Newstart payments erupts, with shots fired relating to Clive Palmer Tanya Plibersek slapped down her colleague Simon Birmingham with a painful burn after a ...

Australian woman dies after plunging...

  • Registered Date: May 13, 2019

Australian woman dies after plunging from cliff in Japan A Melbourne woman had died after falling more than 40 metres from a cliff in Japan. The 60-year-old was walking on the popul...

North Korea fires two short-range mi...

  • Registered Date: May 10, 2019

North Korea fires two short-range missiles North Korea has fired two short-range missiles from its western area, South Korea's military says. North Korea has fired what appear t...

Royal baby: Duke and Duchess of Suss...

  • Registered Date: May 09, 2019

Royal baby: Duke and Duchess of Sussex name son Archie The Duke and Duchess of Sussex have named their newborn son Archie Harrison Mountbatten-Windsor. Introducing him to the camera...

London Bridge attack: 'Every sliding...

  • Registered Date: May 08, 2019

London Bridge attack: 'Every sliding door slid in Sara’s way': Inquest in London Bridge terror attack begins An inquest into the deaths of eight people, including two ...

RBA keeps rates on HOLD ahead of fed...

  • Registered Date: May 07, 2019

RBA keeps rates on HOLD ahead of federal election next week Cash rate announcement for May. Source: Getty Images Despite a roughly-even chance of RBA announcing the first rate movem...

How the tide has turned against Tony...

  • Registered Date: May 03, 2019

How the tide has turned against Tony Abbott Tony Abbott was jeered and booed during his debate with rival Zali Steggall, but this is not the only bad sign for the Warringah MP. It s...

Sydney boy almost loses eye in Targe...

  • Registered Date: May 02, 2019

Sydney boy almost loses eye in Target store accident The parents of a five-year-old Sydney boy say it is lucky their son did not lose an eye after an accident involving a metal hook...

House prices continue to fall, clear...

  • Registered Date: May 01, 2019

House prices continue to fall, clearing way for rate cut The national property market is enduring its biggest fall in values since the global financial crisis, being led down by dou...

Noor guilty of third-degree murder, ...

  • Registered Date: May 01, 2019

Noor guilty of third-degree murder, manslaughter in killing of Justine Ruszczyk Damond Former Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor has been found guilty of third-degree murder an...

Free Girls Only Skate Workshop

  • Registered Date: Apr 30, 2019

Free Girls Only Skate Workshop Description We're super stoked to announce our team up with Inner West Council to conduct FREE ongoing "Female Only" Skate Workshops We'll be ...

Chemical burns and toxic sludge: wor...

  • Registered Date: Apr 29, 2019

Chemical burns and toxic sludge: workers expose shocking conditions inside the Melbourne factory that blew up Long before Melbourne's northern suburbs were choked with acrid smo...

Login